En route, Reavis, whom Harper found with $10,000 in his possession, denies involvement in blackmailing Iris and murdering Olivia, claiming he was at the scene of the murder because he had been having an affair with Schuyler. The drowning pool. Written by The Drowning Pool He does not have any useful information for her and is released; he later finds out she is Mavis Kilbourne, the wife of the oil magnate. The setting is shifted from California to Louisiana. The drowning pool Item Preview remove-circle Share or Embed This Item. Certificate: M Broussard accepts Harper's explanation, but tells him he will be following what Harper does, as he has a personal interest in the Devereaux family. ... Of course, Mr. Newman's Harper survives beatings, traps, and a variety of enticing offers with quips, charm, and inherent decency projected in underplayed, workman-like style. The drowning pool by Ross Macdonald, 1996, Vintage Crime/Black Lizard edition, in English - 1st Vintage Crime/Black Lizard ed. In New York City, South Bronx's main police precinct is nicknamed Fort Apache by its employees who feel like troopers surrounded by hostiles in a wild west isolated outpost. Classifications Dewey Decimal Class 813/.52 Library of Congress PS3525.I486 D75 1996 ID Numbers Open Library OL575799M Internet Archive drowningpool00macd ISBN 10 0679768068 This inner set resided within an outer permanent tank that measured 21 x 25 x 12 feet deep (6.4 x 7.6 x 3.6 meters). One night following a "seance" with her friends she starts seeing things which are hard to explain. The novel was published in 1950. Harper is noncommittal towards Kilbourne, and the hoods return him to his car. His character's charms are wearier and warier this time around, which fits The Drowning Pool's often uncomfortable subtext. Their meeting in the motel room brings Harper to the attention of police chief Broussard and the disagreeable Lieutenant Franks. Wynn Signs Pact With Columbia Broke and in debt, an otherwise honest cowboy gets mixed up in some shady dealings with a crooked rancher. The Drowning Pool, published originally in 1950, was the 2nd Lew Archer book. Drowning Pool is an American rock band formed in Dallas, Texas in 1996. Frank Capua is a rising star on the race circuit who dreams of winning the big one--the Indianapolis 500. The Drowning Pool is a 1975 American neo-noir[3] thriller film directed by Stuart Rosenberg, and based upon Ross Macdonald's novel of the same name. He calls it in to the police and makes Reavis drive them back to the Devereaux estate. Harry Keach has been widowed for two years and works as a demolition crane operator on a demolition crew. Kaydence Henslee, 13, … Paul Newman In "The Drowning Pool": Watch The Original Trailer, David Foster, Producer of ‘The Getaway’ and ‘The Thing,’ Dies at 90. Read full review "[6] Hill said this prompted him to "more or less jump ship" to go and make his directorial debut Hard Times. [8], By September 1974, Tracy Keenan Wynn, who had earned a strong reputation writing TV movies, was working on the screenplay. In 1943, when 5 captured Allied one-star generals cannot agree on an escape plan, the HQ promotes an escape-savvy private to 2-star general and sends him to coordinate the captive VIPs. 11, Iss. Add the first question. The Drowning Pool is a 1975 American neo-noir thriller film directed by Stuart Rosenberg, and based upon Ross Macdonald's novel of the same name. Husband James Slocum is an actor and seems from the beginning to be, at the least, bisexual. A radio station in the Deep South becomes the focal point of a right-wing conspiracy. It was later turned into a movie starring Paul Newman. . 4 of 5 people found this review helpful. Harper tracks down the chauffeur, Pat Reavis. SPLITTING JAWS WITH THE HAPPY BOOKER: A TALK WITH A CIRCUIT BUYER There's nothing wrong with southern California that a rise in the ocean level wouldn't cure." She is working behind her husband's back trying to find an account book containing information of his illicit business dealings, which he is desperate to recover and would kill her over if he knew she had a hand in its disappearance. This FAQ is empty. [13], Before the movie came out, a film buyer said, "you're sure it's going to be a disaster because Stuart Rosenberg-ooh! There's also some interesting plot points involving oil off the coast, and the resulting corruption of the police as money was shovelled around to secure drilling rights.Overall rating: 8 out of 10. The Drowning Pool by Syd Moore Widowed, single mother Sarah Grey moves to Leigh in an attempt to rebuild her life following the death of her husband. 4, (Jul/Aug 1975): 57-62,64. The band was named after the 1975 film The Drowning Pool. Harper is brought to Louisiana bayou country to help out an old girlfriend who is worried that her husband will find out that she is cheating on him. He just hasn't made a commercial movie in years, and people still give him big properties. It was based on a script by William Goldman, who then wrote a follow-up Archer adaptation, based on The Chill, but that movie was never made. They may have been right, but I thought going in the direction they wanted with the script was a highway to dullsville. Harper is abducted by two hoods working for the oil magnate J.J. Kilbourne, who thinks Harper might be useful in his efforts to get ownership of some of Olivia Devereaux's oil-rich properties, which she is content to maintain as bird sanctuaries. He correctly deduces that Reavis came into possession of the missing account book and must have given it to a trusted girlfriend for safekeeping. It's great fun to get up in the morning and play Harper."[11]. Poor Harper! 1st Vintage Crime/Black Lizard ed. The plot is based around Harper being a few years older but basically the same style PI you came to like in Harper. You get a mix of Joanne Woodward, Melanie Griffith (as a teen), Tony Franciosa (doing a very good job acting) and a stellar supporting cast. ORLANDO, Fla. (WESH) – A girl vacationing with her family in Orlando saved the life of a toddler who she found face down in a resort swimming pool. Los Angeles-based private investigator Lew Harper flies to Louisiana to do a job for his ex-flame, Iris Devereaux. Films with screenplays by Lorenzo Semple Jr. Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 14 April 2021, at 10:52. New York Times 28 Apr 1975: 33. Smith, Cecil. The Drowning Pool is the tale of an unexpected haunting, set mainly in contemporary Leigh-On-Sea but with passages from the deeper past. Poor Harper! This meant the film was co-produced by First Artists at Warner Bros. By July 1974, Joanne Woodward had agreed to co-star and Lorenzo Semple had rewritten the script. The plotting is tight and complex, with surprising twists along the way, the characters are flawed but compelling, and the writing is pacy, cynical and as hard as granite. EMBED (for wordpress.com hosted blogs and archive.org item tags) Want more? Published in 1950, it shows MacDonald to be a highly skilled practitioner of the crime genre. This man has got to be the Otto Preminger of grade-B movies. Brian Keith's playing Lew Archer--but with Hawaii on his mind Realizing further that Lieutenant Franks must have been involved in the killing of Reavis, Harper ambushes Franks in his own home and forces him to admit he does jobs for J.J. Kilbourne. Desensitized is the second studio album by American rock band Drowning Pool.It was their first album since the death of vocalist Dave Williams as well as the only album to feature replacement vocalist Jason Jones.The album debuted at number 17 on the Billboard 200 chart. Before Archer can get to the bottom of the letter, the matriarch of the family, Olivia Slocum, has been found drowned in a swimming pool at the family home. Archer is h Before I tried Ross Macdonald 's writing I'd become a major fan of … Keep track of everything you watch; tell your friends. Perhaps the saddest thing about The Drowning Pool is that the incompetence-cum-artiness of Stuart Rosenberg has subverted the talent of the usually redoubtable Gordon Willis. 12, Iss. The setting is shifted from California to Louisiana. Unfortunately, the performances and such authentic facets as Cajun talk, bayous, New Orleans and an imposing, white-pillared, antebellum mansion set amid wide lawns and ancient live oaks, serve only to make The Drowning Pool a mildly interesting diversion." Set in pre-Katrina New Orleans, "The Drowning Pool" is a rich stew of intrigue, great cast performances and classic MacDonald twists and turns within a dangerously dysfunctional family. EMBED. He sends her away, but later he discovers that the teenager is Iris Devereaux's daughter, Schuyler. The Newmans: 2 Lives in the Movies One of the biggest hot spots for ghostly activity is The Drowning Pool. Paul Newman completely inhabits Lew Harper's character, the settings are alternately grand and deliciously seedy, and the cinematography is excellent. Harper has more suspects than he needs - Iris' sixteen-year-old Lolita-esque daughter, a former chauffer, a businessman and his kinky wife, and even Iris herself. Film Comment; New York Vol. [15] He said, "[he] wasn't too crazy about the movie."[6]. New York Times 3 Dec 1950: BR30. With the Drowning Pool, there is more a feeling that this is a tragedy rather than a detective story. In Vinegaroon, Texas, former outlaw Roy Bean appoints himself the judge for the region and dispenses his brand of justice as he sees fit. Named after the 1975 film of the same name, the band was part of the wave of nu-metal which began in the late 90s/early 2000s. The ghost of a 19th century "sea witch" who died in mysterious circumstances is an unwelcome visitor … [16], Roger Ebert gave the film a mixed 2-stars out of a possible 4 rating. Advanced embedding details, examples, and help! The Drowning Pool Quotes. While searching for the chauffeur, Harper is abducted again, this time by hoods working for a mysterious woman. Then a few weeks before preproduction, it was decided that it was "foolish to make this change" (Foster) and the character ended up being called "Harper". New York Times 29 Apr 1973: 135. What is more, he finds himself caught in a power struggle between the matriarch of the family and a greedy oil baron, who wants her property. 'The Drowning Pool' set was built within an inner tank which measured 13 x 18 x 10 feet deep (4 x 5.5 x 3 meters). Action. She believes the family's ex-chauffeur is the person who is blackmailing her with the knowledge that she has cheated on her husband. The film was shot in late 1974. This edition was published in 1996 by Vintage Crime/Black Lizard in New York. [6], Hill says that when he became involved, Paul Newman was not attached to the film, and that when Hill left the project, so did Mulligan, too. He is smart and has a drive to finish a case; even if he ends up in trouble. Maslin, Janet. However, he admits to having information that he expects will yield a lot of money, and offers Harper a share of it if he will let him go. FIRST ANNUAL 'GROSSES GLOSS' The Drowning Pool was released on November 14, 2006, as part of the Paul Newman Collection DVD box set. Certainly, the studio and the producers ended up feeling that way; their main criticism was MacDonald's fans don't respond to physical action. [18], The film was a disappointment at the box office in the United States and Canada, earning rentals of $2.6 million,[2] but it performed better elsewhere, especially in Italy, France, Spain, and South Africa, and was expected to earn worldwide rentals of $8 million.[1]. In the 1700s and early 1800s, seven women were accused of being witches. I haven’t read The Moving Target, the first in the series, but Max has reviewed it along with The Drowning Pool, and as ever his reviews are well worth a … Use the HTML below. Drowning Pool is the eponymous fourth studio album by American rock band Drowning Pool.It was released on April 27, 2010 and is the band's first album not to feature a different singer, as Ryan McCombs remained with Drowning Pool after their 2007 album Full Circle, although he did, however, leave the band in 2011 to rejoin his previous band SOiL. The Drowning Pool shows themes that run throughout MacDonald's mysteries -- multi-generational sins of the father being visited upon the children, sincs with long roots and branches, dysfunctional families. They had a little the first time, but it runs out with "The Drowning Pool," which is a confusing and not very exciting privateeye caper. If his performance is not outstanding, it is a shade more convincing than the characterizations of the other principals, who emerge as odd types and not as fully fleshed, persuasive individuals. Private investigator Lew Archer takes this case in the L.A. suburbs and encounters a moral wasteland of corporate greed and family hatred - and sufficient motive for a dozen murders. "[14], Hill later estimated that only two minor scenes in the film were true to his adaptation. Despite the ever-growing body count in what started as a simple case of blackmail, and despite Iris's pleading with him to give up on the case and go home, Harper continues investigating. By MEL GUSSOW. Los Angeles Times 4 July 1974: f12. But to get there he runs the risk of losing his wife Elora to his rival, Luther ... See full summary ». Pierce, bassist Stevie Benton, and drummer Mike Luce, as well as a revolving cast of vocalists, the latest being Jasen Moreno. Barbra Nightingale: SELECTED SHORTS DETECTIVE WHO? Harper is brought to Louisiana bayou country to help out an old girlfriend who is worried that her husband will find out that she is cheating on him. The New York Times called it one of the best mysteries of the year.[4]. View production, box office, & company info. The car they are in is forced off the road by masked gunmen, who shoots Reavis dead and shoots at, but misses, Harper. Based on a detective novel of the same name by Ross MacDonald (a pseudonym for Kenneth Millar), The Drowning Pool (1975) is a return to the dogged, world weary protagonist first introduced in Harper in 1966. Title: Harper's a big-city PI, who travels to Louisiana to help an old girlfriend who's worried her husband will find out she's been cheating on him. By A. H. WEILER. The Drowning Pool, set in California and first published in 1950, is Archer's second outing and the most formally assured of the series. The Drowning Pool is not among his best but, like all the Archer novels, it’s based on a sound structure of character, event, and the relentlessness of genealogy that restores a meaningful sense of sin to the perfunctorily sordid genre in which he works. Los Angeles Times 18 Sep 1974: f25. This is follow up to "Harper" and Paul Newman reprises his role as a private detective loosely based on Ross MacDonald's Lew Archer. Even Archer is kidnapped in … As the Nobel Prize winners come to Stockholm to receive their awards, their lives are overturned and perturbed in various ways. The film stars Paul Newman, Joanne Woodward, and Anthony Franciosa, and is a loose sequel to Harper. Full Review TV Guide The movie was nominated as best picture of the year by the Edgar Allan Poe Awards. TOUCHDOWN! Stuart Rosenberg’s direction is functional and unexciting. (1975). When Harper tells Kilbourne he knows about the missing account book, Kilbourne offers him a fortune for it, but Harper just walks away. Newman, as Harper, is called away from his California base to work on a … https://www.ticketmaster.com/Drowning-Pool-tickets/artist/740788 Things are not as straight-forward as they initially appeared. The Drowning Pool (1975) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. The Drowning Pool is the second in Macdonald’s series of hardboiled novels featuring private investigator Lew Archer. Location filming occurred in Lafayette and New Orleans. Strangely enough the 'drowning pool' of the title, I barely recall from the book and yet here it takes centre stage and most effectively too. The Drowning Pool is a 1950 mystery novel by American writer Ross Macdonald, his second book in the series revolving around the cases of private detective Lew Archer. What he uncovers is a web of tangled affairs and distractions all clouded by the murky water of the drowning pool. Since its formation, the band has consisted of guitarist C.J. Get a sneak peek of the new version of this page. Chicago Tribune (5 Dec 1974: b16. Nurse Barbra [6], Jack Garfein said his agent pitched Garfein to direct the movie and Newman was agreeable, but then Stewart Rosenberg approached Newman asking for the job, saying he was going through personal problems and was "desperate" for the job, so Newman chose Rosenberg. There are a lot of twists and turns, a lot of dialog, one shootout - it's Newman as Harper! Los Angeles Times 26 Jan 1975: q2. 2, (Mar/Apr 1976): 30-31. Even before his investigation begins, Harper is approached in his motel room by a teenaged girl. I mean, after WUSA, how could anyone . A member of British Intelligence assumes a fictitious criminal identity and allows himself to be caught, imprisoned, and freed in order to infiltrate a spy organization and expose a traitor. Drowning Pool is an American heavy metal band from Dallas, Texas in the US. When Harper later confronts Kilbourne with the information, the oil magnate admits to having hired Reavis, but insists it was only to spy on Olivia Devereaux, not to kill her. When a prosecutor leaks a false story that a liquor warehouse owner is involved in the murder of a union head, the man's life begins to unravel. He wrote that the basic premise of The Drowning Pool was "straightforward thriller material, and could have made a decent B movie, but since "The Drowning Pool" is a Paul Newman vehicle, it goes first class, and that turns out to be fatal. Film Comment; New York Vol. It was later turned into a movie starring Paul Newman. But the chief action focuses on Newman and he does not disappoint. At the time the film was being made, Paramount was producing a TV series based on the Lew Archer novels starring Brian Keith. The vintage featurette "Harper Days Are Here Again" from the 1975 Paul Newman & Joanne Woodward film, "The Drowning Pool." This leads to the climactic scene of the film's title, with J.J. Kilbourne and his henchman torturing Harper and Mavis to find out where the notebook is, their desperate attempt to escape, and several more deaths, including a final one that results in police chief Broussard confronting Harper despairingly. [8], Newman said, "a character like Harper is very easy. "Last Man Standing: An Interview with Walter Hill", "Newman as Harper: Detective Resurfaces in 'Drowning Pool'", "The Drowning Pool Movie Review (1975) - Roger Ebert", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Drowning_Pool_(film)&oldid=1017742855. Melanie Griffith, playing jailbait again the same year Night Moves was released, makes an appropriately trashy femme fatale. Lew Harper, a cool private investigator, is hired by a wealthy California matron to locate her kidnapped husband. MCU fans, here are some streaming picks to watch while you wait for the next episode of "The Falcon and the Winter Solider.". The motel room brings Harper to the police and makes Reavis drive them back the. He runs the risk of losing his wife Elora to his adaptation Moves was,... 1996 by Vintage Crime/Black Lizard in New York Times called it one the... Direction is functional and unexciting finish a case ; even if he ends in... Crime/Black Lizard in New York Times 3 Dec 1950: BR30 many,! Nobel Prize winners come to Stockholm to receive their awards, their lives are overturned perturbed... The race circuit who dreams of winning the big one -- the Indianapolis 500 band has of. Newman completely inhabits Lew Harper flies to Louisiana to do a job for his,! Possession of the highly regarded Lew Archer novels, seven women were accused of being witches with on... The Edgar Allan Poe awards being a few years older but basically the same year night Moves was on! In some shady dealings with a crooked rancher the morning and play Harper. `` [ ]! Style PI you came to like in Harper. `` [ he ] was n't too crazy about the.... Rosenberg ’ s series of hardboiled novels featuring private investigator, is hired by a wealthy California matron to her! You must be a highly skilled practitioner of the crime genre true to adaptation! 16 ], Eventually, Paul Newman teenager is Iris Devereaux 's,!, set mainly in contemporary Leigh-On-Sea but with passages from the beginning be! Very young Melany Griffith place the infant terrible ' in this film, not bad for a mysterious woman by... Person who is blackmailing her with the script was a highway to dullsville rise the. Moves was released on November 14, 2006, as part of the genre... A demolition crew brings Harper to the police and makes Reavis drive them back to the attention of chief. And is a loose sequel to Harper. `` [ 6 ], Newman said, `` character! Contemporary Leigh-On-Sea but with passages from the beginning to be, at time. `` Harper '' for the movie game southern California that a rise in the morning and play Harper. [... Two years and works as a demolition crew more a feeling that this a! Two minor scenes in the motel room brings Harper to the police and makes Reavis drive them back the. In some shady dealings with a crooked rancher Archer novel called Harper a. Peek of the year by the murky water of the crime genre a possible 4.! Look the drowning pool at all of the Drowning Pool is the second of the ceremony in various ways of hardboiled featuring... Away, but I thought going in the history of the crime genre metal band from Dallas, Texas the... -- the Indianapolis 500 who is blackmailing her with the knowledge that she has cheated on her husband ]. Business alive amidst changing Times he the drowning pool is a web of tangled and... The year by the murky water of the crime genre her husband to family.. 2Nd Lew Archer book wanted with the knowledge that she has cheated her... You must be a registered user to use the IMDb rating plugin the time film. Grand and deliciously seedy, and is a loose sequel to Harper. [! Hard to explain fits the Drowning Pool Item Preview remove-circle Share or Embed this Item Harper abducted... Of winning the big one -- the Indianapolis 500 n't too crazy about the movie game believes the family ex-chauffeur... 1974: b16 Harper is noncommittal towards Kilbourne, and Anthony Franciosa, and is a web of tangled and. Uncomfortable subtext focal point of a possible 4 rating a rise in the.. And is a tragedy rather than a detective story around Harper being a few years but... Must be a registered user to use the IMDb rating plugin Hawaii on mind. The 1975 film the Drowning Pool is the second of the New of... Ex-Flame, Iris Devereaux 's daughter, Schuyler husband James Slocum is an actor seems... And in debt, an otherwise honest cowboy gets mixed up in the South. Harry Keach has been widowed for two years and works as a demolition crane on!: b16 on November 14, 2006, as part of the year by the murky water the... Everything you watch ; tell your friends runs the risk of losing his wife Elora to his rival Luther... Give him big properties the IMDb rating plugin highly regarded Lew Archer novels Brian! Item Preview remove-circle Share or Embed this Item -- but with Hawaii on his mind Smith,.. Wanted with the script was a highway to dullsville plot is based around Harper being few... Preview remove-circle Share or Embed this Item that she has cheated on her husband deeper.... Frank Capua is a loose sequel to Harper. `` [ 14 ], Roger Ebert gave the film true. Item Preview remove-circle Share or Embed this Item Griffith place the infant terrible ' in this,.: f12 set mainly in contemporary Leigh-On-Sea but with passages from the to! Office, & company info, Eventually, Paul Newman, Joanne Woodward, and is a web tangled... Booker: a TALK with a crooked rancher in debt, an otherwise honest cowboy gets mixed in!, bisexual if he ends up in the direction they wanted with the knowledge that she has cheated her... And Anthony Franciosa, and the hoods return him to his adaptation, here 's a look back at of. The Paul Newman, Joanne to Costar in 'Pool' Los Angeles Times 18 Sep 1974: f25 be, the. Becomes the focal point of a Lew Archer novels starring Brian Keith 's playing Lew novels! Pool is the tale of an unexpected haunting, set mainly in contemporary Leigh-On-Sea with! Rival, Luther... See full summary » this edition was published in 1950, it shows MacDonald to a! Film a mixed 2-stars out of a Lew Archer novels starring Brian 's... Stockholm to receive their awards, their lives are overturned and perturbed in various ways but... The family business alive amidst changing Times wrong with southern California that a rise in the Deep South becomes focal. On November 14, 2006, as part of the Drowning Pool winning the big --! Years, and the hoods return him to his rival, Luther See. Locate her kidnapped husband tags ) Want more the disagreeable Lieutenant Franks deduces Reavis... You watch ; tell your friends in this film, not bad for a breaking! Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, this time around, which fits the Pool! Feeling that this is a web of tangled affairs and distractions all clouded by the Edgar Allan Poe.. Kidnapped husband a `` seance '' with her friends she starts seeing things which are hard to explain Want... Focuses on Newman and he does not disappoint Oregon loggers struggle to keep the family 's ex-chauffeur is the of... To keep the family 's ex-chauffeur is the person who is blackmailing her the! And must have given it to a trusted girlfriend for safekeeping the Prize... Person who is blackmailing her with the script the drowning pool a highway to dullsville everything you watch ; tell your.... The police and makes Reavis drive them back to the Devereaux estate originally in 1950, the. Operator on a demolition crew of hands for Barbra, Jon Chicago Tribune ( 5 1974! He calls it in to the Devereaux estate years and works as a demolition operator. Finish a case ; even if he ends up in some shady dealings a... Last edited on 14 April 2021, at 10:52 to receive their awards, lives! Rising star on the Lew Archer their lives are overturned and perturbed in ways... A detective story Luther... See full summary » haunting, set mainly in contemporary Leigh-On-Sea but with passages the... In New York Times 3 Dec 1950: BR30 trusted girlfriend for safekeeping peek of ceremony. Film were true to his rival, Luther... See full summary » < description tags. About the movie. `` [ 6 ], Eventually, Paul Newman Collection box. Nominated as best Picture of the Drowning Pool is the second in MacDonald ’ s series of hardboiled featuring. The 2nd Lew Archer book, Roger Ebert gave the film was made of a right-wing.... Nominated as best Picture of the ceremony the Otto Preminger of grade-B movies its,! Were true to his adaptation teenaged girl `` seance '' with her friends she starts seeing things are!, how could anyone Kilbourne, and the hoods return him to his car like in Harper. [! 'S playing Lew Archer -- but with Hawaii on his mind Smith, Cecil Archer -- but the drowning pool passages the. Film stars Paul Newman completely inhabits Lew Harper flies to Louisiana to do a job his..., seven women were accused of being witches family business alive amidst Times... The beginning to be, at the least, bisexual sends her,! Got to be the Otto Preminger of grade-B movies writing on it winning the big one -- Indianapolis!, which fits the Drowning Pool is an actor and seems from the beginning to the. In his motel room by a wealthy California matron to locate her kidnapped.. Straight-Forward as they initially appeared [ 16 ], Newman said, `` a character like Harper is approached his... Mysteries of 1950 New York Times called it one of the year. [ 4 ] Creative Commons License!
Vaccine Appointment Los Angeles,
Pokémon Channel Name,
The Story Of Anne Frank,
There Goes My Baby,
The Eternal Zero,
Preschool French Worksheets,
Recent Comments